Underpayment

Minimum payments under various Awards, Enterprise Agreements and employment contracts has been a complex issue in Australia for a long time. This is because negotiations regarding wages have varied greatly between workplaces, the type of work performed, and the years of experience and/or level of the employee.

Underpayments

Mistakes have consistently been made in the calculation of wages. This has resulted in underpayment of wages, often spanning over many years. It is unlawful to underpay an employee and significant penalties may apply.

To identify an underpayment is time-consuming and depends on many factors including:

  • proper classification of the work being undertaken by the employee;
  • the age of the employee;
  • the level at which the employee is performing the work;
  • the days on which the work is performed by the employee;
  • the number of hours an employee is working per day;
  • whether or not allowances (i.e. clothing or meals) apply. These are usually unique to a workplace/industry; and
  • whether an employee has the benefit of an old award because they did not sign up to, or become bound by, a more recent industrial agreement such as an Enterprise Agreement.

When large numbers of employees are involved against big employers (e.g. Coles or Woolworths), the Fair Work Ombudsman has been known to take a keen interest in enforcing the agreement. Where a small employer is concerned, the same rules apply but with less fanfare.

After an underpayment is identified, it can take 6 months for the Fair Work Ombudsman to make a ruling. Often it is a ruling which the employee disagrees with. Whether or not they agree, it is usually left up to the employee to engage their own lawyer to then bring a legal proceeding against the employer for the amount of underpayment.

Underpaid employees should consider whether or not to fast track the process by going straight to a lawyer even though this can be a more expensive process, at least in the beginning. McDonald Murholme offers assistance in the calculation and the legal action to recover underpayments.

We Listen To You

Get in touch with the employment lawyer who has acted for thousands of employees like you.

    We offer a fast,
    efficient and affordable service which is highly personalised.

    The McDonald Murholme team is headed by Mr Alan McDonald.

    Contact Us
    Frequently asked underpayment law questions
    How do I know if I am being underpaid?

    To determine if you are being underpaid, you need to find out the correct rate at which you should be paid. This can be affected by a range of factors including, whether you are full-time or part-time, whether you are casual or permanent, whether you are a trainee or apprentice, your age and your qualifications. You can contact the Fair Work Ombudsman to find out if you are entitled to be paid above the National Employment Standards pursuant to a modern award or enterprise agreement.

    Can I file an underpayment claim in relation to a former job?

    You can bring a claim for historical underpayments, however, this is subject to a six-year time limit under subsection 545(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). For example, an employee who files an underpayment claim on 1 January 2020 can seek an order to recover any underpayments that occurred after 1 January 2014.

    I am an independent contractor. Am I eligible to file underpayments claims?

    You are more likely to be deemed an independent contractor if you invoice the entity for whom you perform work. This is a matter of negotiation between the independent contractor and the principal and as such, independent contractors are not afforded the same legal protection for pay rates and minimum terms and conditions of employment as employees.

    Independent contractors are not entitled to a minimum rate of pay or conditions such as annual leave, personal leave, parental leave, long service leave and redundancy entitlements. Further, independent contractors cannot file a claim with the Fair Work Ombudsman to recover underpayments for work performed and will need to commence legal proceedings in either an eligible court or the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of their state instead.

    Are you being underpaid?

    Speak to an employment lawyer who has acted for thousands of employees like you.

    Our clients' satisfaction is pivotal to our own success.
    • quote

      “The McDonald Murholme staff made me feel so comfortable, they provided me with great advice and helped me reach an outcome that I was very… more

      rating image
      quote

      “The McDonald Murholme staff made me feel so comfortable, they provided me with great advice and helped me reach an outcome that I was very happy with.”

      rating image
      Sophie Thomson
      Sophie Thomson
    • quote

      “Thank you, Edward, Alan and the team. Your support throughout the journey was outstanding. I cannot recommend you enough. I could not be happier. Thank… more

      rating image
      quote

      “Thank you, Edward, Alan and the team. Your support throughout the journey was outstanding. I cannot recommend you enough. I could not be happier. Thank you again.”

      rating image
      Joanne Ferretto
      Joanne Ferretto
    • quote

      “Alan and Stephanie were able to turn my workplace nightmare into a financially rewarding experience that I would never have been able to achieve without… more

      rating image
      quote

      “Alan and Stephanie were able to turn my workplace nightmare into a financially rewarding experience that I would never have been able to achieve without their knowledge and assistance. I am so grateful for the exit strategy they managed to negotiate for me to enable me to move on to a much better opportunity. Huge thanks to all the team at McDonald Murholme for the great work you all do.”

      rating image
      Camden Brown
      Camden Brown
    • quote

      “Alan, Ned and the team at McDonald Murholme took a genuine interest in my situation. Their advice and guidance helped me quickly achieve a fair… more

      rating image
      quote

      “Alan, Ned and the team at McDonald Murholme took a genuine interest in my situation. Their advice and guidance helped me quickly achieve a fair settlement from my employer.”

      rating image
      Anonymous
      Anonymous
    • quote

      “My need for support from McDonald Murholme came at a time when I was also focussing on a couple of other personal issues - both… more

      rating image
      quote

      “My need for support from McDonald Murholme came at a time when I was also focussing on a couple of other personal issues - both significant but unrelated. The support I received from Alan, Stephanie and the team was incredible - I felt supported at every step of the process and was 100% confident that the matter was being dealt with effectively whilst I addressed other things. Most importantly, however, the team were easy to talk to and kept me fully up to date with progress. Hopefully I'll not have a need to use them again but, if I do, I absolutely would NOT hesitate! Last thing for me to say - THANK YOU McDonald Murholme!”

      rating image
      PJ Metcalf
      PJ Metcalf
    • quote

      “Alan, Julie and the team at McDonald Murholme helped me through a very stressful time with my employer. Once I contacted and engaged them they… more

      rating image
      quote

      “Alan, Julie and the team at McDonald Murholme helped me through a very stressful time with my employer. Once I contacted and engaged them they kept me informed and supported me throughout the journey. They took away my stress, were patient with my many questions and most importantly they empowered me. Highly recommend.”

      rating image
      Tiffany Richards
      Tiffany Richards
    • quote

      “Outstanding, clear and concise advice.”

      rating image
      Carl Pallier
    • quote

      “Deeply compassionate, understanding and supportive, Helped me through a very difficult decision with sage and timely advice.”

      rating image
      Ian Stokol